2 min readAug 9, 2024

It says the sun sets in spring of warm water in the Quran chapter you just cited, same thing it says in the Hadith you just called weak. Is this a scientific statement?

Why are there so many weak things in Islamic sources anyway? Are you saying that Muslims are lying about the prophet to fellow Muslims?

Regarding the prophet being poisoned I have the references in my article "why we cannot trust Muhammad part 3" look at it there. In his own words and according to Aisha he died from the poison at Kaiba and he felt it in his heart and I noticed you said nothing about ajua dates and how if you eat it you cannot be poisoned, is this scientific?

Regarding the sex slaves, you have not answered my question at all other than saying Allah himself commanded it (which would be even worse). But is that in line with human rights? Sleeping with women against their will and in the presence of their husbands?

You have spoken about men and women but this does not answer the question. Your prophet said you can beat your wife. Is this in line with human rights???

You say women matured fast in Arabia. And at 9 they were mature. Really? Do we have any historical evidence for that? Again, why does it say in the Hadith that Aisha was still playing with dolls when the prophet was having sex with her? Specifically says dolls are haram but it was permitted for Aisha because she was young. How mature could she have been if she was still playing with dolls?

Again, I like that you defend drinking of camel urine, the reader can make their own mind up on that, I have nothing to add.

Leave Islam my friend, you sound like a nice guy. Way nicer than Muhammad in fact. You have no business following this indefensible prophet. You are better than defending sex with nine year olds and drinking of camel urine.

A.B. Melchizedek
A.B. Melchizedek

Written by A.B. Melchizedek

Crusader waging offensive war on ideas that exalt themselves against the knowledge of Christ (particularly Islam) & defending the logic of the Christian faith.

Responses (1)