They both care about you.

One cares about your eternal salvation and hopes to being you to a saving knowledge of Jesus Christ whose death and resurrection have a strong historical basis.

The other wants you dead for not believing in it irrespective of your degree of interest in it.

If Jesus indeed rose from the dead then His claims ought to be taken seriously and there are implications for everyone, irrespective of what they believe about Him.

I recommend you look into the evidence for Christianity.

God bless